Disclosing financials to prospects: Good or bad?
Back in the beginning of March I posted this on Twitter:
Then, just yesterday, I posted this:
You can see this has been on my mind.Prospective clients (often big companies with legal departments or government agencies) will require you submit your financial statements to them as a condition of an RFP. The idea behind that is so the organization can minimize their risk by making sure that you're financially solvent. They don't want to engage with a company that might be here today and gone tomorrow, because it will cost them time and money to re-engage with someone else if you end up disappearing. The information can also shed some light on how your company has (or hasn't grown) over the years, and which way you're currently trending. Its a value estimator. It all sounds perfectly reasonable on paper, right?
Well, we don't accommodate those requests.
Why? Well, I wish I had a better answer other than, "It's none of their business." But that's it.
Sure, you can sign an NDA so there are assurances they won't go discussing your numbers with anyone else. But for me, an oragnization that asks to see your books is an organization that probably didn't have you on their radar in the first place, or at least not on their short list. If you're responding to an RFP, you can be assured you're one of umpteen other companies that is also responding to the RFP. The way I see it, if an organization really wants to work with you, they won't treat you like a number. They'll take the time to look at your work, ask you tough questions, understand your history, read your articles, and talk to references you provide them (which, for the record, I think is a perfectly reasonable thing to do). The health of your organization will be evident by your longevity, your client roster, your thought leadership, and most importantly, your body of work. It won't be based whole or in part on how much profit you made or what your accounts payable balance looks like.
I see it as a filtering mechanism, much like I view requests for spec work. It's a safe bet that if you're asked to show how much money your company makes (or doesn't make) or what kind of work you'll do for free to prove your worth, you're not being considered for what makes you truly valuable.




Comments [6]